Charm BarMixed Metals
Gold JewelryIn-Stock Items
RingsBracelets
EarringsNecklaces
Tees & SweatshirtsNavajo Pearls
Dainty & Everyday PiecesOne-of-a-Kind Pieces
SALE TABClothing + Bags

2026 Cleanout Sale

30%+ off select items for our 2026 Cleanout Sale! Cleaning out inventory before our next big drop! Sale ends 01.23. No code needed, discount will automatically apply at checkout!

View all

New Arrivals

1 12
View all

Meet the Maker

Hey y’all! I’m Taylor, the hands behind the handmade here at The Sterling Pony. I love sunshine, good jewelry, palomino ponies, & Jesus. My favorite color & coffee is mocha. I was born & raised in Wayne County, Ohio. I currently silversmith full time in my shop, right at home in Apple Creek where my husband and I live; I love what I get to do & could never fully express the gratitude I have for you all who continually blow me away with your support.

I hope through The Sterling Pony that I am able to provide you with jewelry that you can wear and enjoy for years, return some of the love y’all have show me, & above all, share the joy and hope that I’ve found in Jesus Christ.

“I pray that out of his glorious riches he may strengthen you with power through his Spirit in your inner being, so that Christ may dwell in your hearts through faith. & I pray that you, being rooted & established in love, may have power, together with all the Lord’s holy people, to grasp how wide & long & high & deep is the love of Christ, & to know this love that surpasses knowledge—that you may be filled to the measure of all the fullness of God.” Ephesians 3:16-19

Blessings, friends.

Taylor

Let customers speak for us

from 95 reviews
absolutely beautiful made the perfect

absolutely beautiful made the perfect gift

Emily
The Silver Abide Necklaces
The Silver Abide Necklaces
The bracelets were beautiful and my daughters loved them (as always)

The bracelets were beautiful and my daughters loved them (as always).

Jamie Imhoff
The Maisie Bracelet
The Maisie Bracelet
Perfect gift!

This is perfect for my daughter - classic and simple, perfect for daily wear. I’ve been looking for just the right cross necklace to replace one she lost, and this one was just right. Beautiful but understated and not flashy, and the beaded chain adds just the right amount of detail. Thank you!

Sheila Burns
The Cross Necklace
The Cross Necklace
My daughter loved it

My daughter loved it. She picked it out because her late Grandmother was named Cordelia.

LINDA KROEKER
The Cordelia Necklace
The Cordelia Necklace
Gift

Got them for my sister as a gift. She loved them!

Jordan Kitzmiller
The Eva Earrings
The Eva Earrings
Necklace

It is great!

Dax Gardner
The Silver Abide Necklaces
The Silver Abide Necklaces

I bought it as a gift. She loved it and wears it every day!

Lisa
The Elaine Beaded Stretch Bracelets
The Elaine Beaded Stretch Bracelets
Wyonna hoops

They were a gift but she loved them!

Anonymous
The Wyonna Hoops
The Wyonna Hoops
Great turn out

Great turn out thanks

Paxton
The Sterling Silver Turquoise Charm
The Sterling Silver Turquoise Charm
Love

So cute!

Anonymous
The Jolene Cuffs
The Jolene Cuffs
My daughter is going to love

My daughter is going to love this!

Anonymous
The Rooney Cuff
The Rooney Cuff
Beautiful horse pendant necklace

Beautiful horse pendant necklace, both the chain, and the charm! Customer service was great, along with quick shipping!! I’m very pleased, and highly recommend this shop.

Eve Pickren
The Gold Fill Dainty Chain
The Gold Fill Dainty Chain
Galilee Necklace

Love this necklace. Western flare with the twisted cross and just a dainty small turquoise is perfect for daily wear. Perfect as always. I buy all my turquoise for the SterlingPony!

Anonymous
The Galilee Necklace
The Galilee Necklace
Perfect

Perfect

Shan Ryan
The Cutter Ring
The Cutter Ring
Very pretty & dainty ring

Very pretty & dainty ring. The ring was a little smaller in diameter than I had imagined but still pretty & well made!

Anonymous
The Eva Ring
The Eva Ring
Button label